$begingroup$ I am not sure what you necessarily mean by "cross" results - the only real correlation is that they each are features of your transform in underlying ($Delta S$) For making The 2 techniques equivalent you should consider investing/borrowing $PnL_1$ at amount $r$ to ensure that it stays from https://pnl58898.blogofchange.com/34713526/the-greatest-guide-to-pnl